Unfortunately we don't keep records as to why a card receives an Authentic grade, but as has been mentioned here, it is likely due to trimming, a miscut that was too severe for a numerical grade, or a deviation from the size requirement that was too much for a numerical grade.
You can send the card back to us with your next order or send it in solo for an explanation. Please call or e-mail to arrange that if interested.
Thanks,
Brian
1-800-742-9212 x114
|