I personally think that Tony handled the situation with Chicago206 all wrong.
What Tony should have done was e-mail Chicago and the competing buyer, informing both of them that he was going to cut the card in half, and sell a half to each of them (at a 50% discount off the original price, of course).
Then, Tony should have waited for an e-mail reply from each pursurer of the card. The buyer who indicated that he would rather see the card go to his rival than to see the card cut in half would then be identified as the one true owner of the card (spiritually and metaphysically speaking, of course). Tony should have then sold the card to that individual.
That's the formal sales policy that I apply in such situations on my site anyway...
|