[Scott Garner]

Originally Posted by toyman55

would like some opinions on these two autographs. After much research I feel they are real.

cy young
and
nap lajoie

http://www.jpegbay.com/gallery-demo/512866.html

let me know your thoughts.

Cy Young does not look good to me. The "Y" in Young looks like a the way he formed his "C" in Cy. Also, the "g" in Young does not appear to be right at all. The sequence of pen strokes is totally different than how he formed the top portion of the "g". Just my opinion, but I collect his signature. I can't comment on Nap Lajoie.
I hope you find this helpful!