I'm with Jimmy. Its Gehrig all the way.
First. My favorite piece in my collection.
Second. Has the additional benefits of involving Ruth. And, if I am allowed I can read the paper as well.
Third. Fits all my collecting interests. Gehrig, autographs, and off the beaten path. Plus there is just something really cool about it. Of course, I would fix the glass first.
My only other question would be if a set of cards would count as one item or not. If so, I would leave off the Midweek Pictorial and bring the 1934 Goudey autographed set I am working on.