[kkkkandp]

Besides the aforementioned Kid Nichols I would include:

Jake Beckley - Saint Louis Whites
Bobby Lowe - Milwaukee Brewers
Deacon McGuire - Toronto Canucks
Orator Shafer - Des Moines Prohibitionists
George Treadway - Saint Paul Apostles, Denver Grizzlies

All five of these guys were solid players and one wound up being a HOFer.