Thanks guys, I appreciate it. Another mystery solved - for me anyway.
Yea brianp-beme, they are too similar, with just the faintest of details that make them different. Mostly the lettering on the cap of Tinker and a mole at the right of his lips.
Actually, I'm still questioning this.
On this card, his right eye seems to have been "filled in" and the left eye seems to be looking left, which is different from what I have. It may be just a blemish on the card or a bad scan and I don't have a scan at the moment, so can someone with this card do a comparison?
http://cgi.ebay.com/1910-E91-America...#ht_500wt_1182
Thanks,