The grade is definitely debatable, but if anything I think it serves as an example that you should always see a card before you buy it, regardless of the grade.
Even if the grade is technically correct, many buyers would obviously have buyers remorse for paying an SGC 40 price on this card once they had it in hand, if they hadn't seen it ahead of time.
Disregarding the player, I've seen many Old Judge A's, 1, and 2's recently on this board alone, I would prefer to have over this card, strictly from an aesthetic sense.
Others, I am guessing wouldn't mind. It's all in ones particular tastes I guess.
|