This is Bill's card... best I can do with what he sent me. We need to send him a teenager so he can learn software and hardware.
Great card, Bill!!!!
I think both cards depict Gene. His younger brother, Leon or "Lee", played for St. Louis in a few games in 1903. Lee's last year in organized ball seems to have been 1905, with Charleston in the Sally League, as a player manager. (He'd have seen that scrappy kid with Augusta in 1905, Ty Cobb.
So I think that both cards show Gene. There was only one DeMontreville with New Orleans in 1909 and 1910, Gene, or Eugene.