How long has it been since you e-mailed him? What condition did he describe the cards as being in?
Did you bid more then you would have had you known the pen marks were on the back?
I've always been hesitant to give negatives as a buyer simply because I sell quite a bit and realize sometimes mistakes can be made every once in awhile.
At the same time, as a seller I try to rectify all problems that might arise if possible and get a little annoyed when other sellers don't do the same. I'll also give buyers a lot of leeway as far as payment terms and how long some of them take to actually pay. I guess, I'm kind of wishy washy and give most people the benefit of the doubt on both sides, sometimes to my own detriment.
I guess you do what you think is best given the circumstance. Hopefully, you've given the seller enough time to respond to your complaints.
There's always the DSR's if you're not comfortable giving a negative also.
|