My Colgans of Orville M. Selby, who pitched for Louisville in 1909, then has a gap in his minor league records until he pitches for the Danville Speakers of the 3 I League.
I get them mixed up, as Colgans did, but I think that image is of Seabaugh or Wiesman... I have a Colgans with each name and the same image, showing the left side of the guy's face. I think that's Wiesman. So the image I don't have would be Seabaugh, and he's looking forward...
So I'm guessing that's Seabaugh's image with a Selby caption. I think what you have would be after Mr. Colgan sold his stuff to Auto-Sales, or whoever. That would be the red border cards. When looking at the backs, the E254 Colgans and the Tin Tops have "Colgan's" on the back... the red border cards don't mention "Colgan's" on the back.
Nice Selby's, Tom!!!!