[Archive]

Posted By: Fred C

Ed,

Caruthers only pitched 9 seasons but he did participate for 10 years. For some reason or other people don't include his 1893 participation. I think a big part of Caruthers not being in the HOF is because he played a bulk of his career in the AA.

There is a 19th century pitcher with 297 lifetime wins. If he'd only won three more games he'd be in the HOF. Three lousy wins...