Posted By:
Jon CanfieldDan - I think this is a very interesting question. Let's change it up a bit now - I don't think it's out of the question that Moose gets to 300 wins (I think he can stay around with some small market teams for another 3 years and at 10 wins a season, he could get there).
So, let's say Mussina gets to 300 wins - now is he a HOF'er?
Edited to add, I say yes - 300 wins makes him a HOF'er. While the 500 hr club may be diluted, the 300 win club is not. Would I say it is a lock, no - but I think it would be hard denying entry for a guy that obviously is durable enough to get to 300 wins.