[Archive]

Posted By: Mark

At this point, I'd vote NO as well. A very good pitcher, but not quite HOF credentials, as eloquently pointed out in the posts above. Nothing accomplished in the post-season really hurts his cause.

What about Schilling? Really, the opposite scenario of a Mussina... Great post-season heroics, but not quite as good career stats (and will likely finish with less wins than Mussina). I think Schilling is the ultimate borderline guy. He may be better-liked, and therefore may stand a slightly better chance.