Posted By:
BcDScott is correct it matters not what someone paid for something. Simple fact is Scott was not there when Toby paid $250 for the card and regardless Scott is happy with it and also has a right not to sell it for a loss. Maybe you and he do not agree on the value either but that is not going to help you acquire the card. Don't mess with Scott as he is knowledgeable and like Teflon on here! Sounds like Toby got a good deal on the card as well. Good for him. he is one shrewd card dealer! 
BcD