[Archive]

Posted By: Matt

I appreciate all of the well thought out responses. What I was hoping for is that we would come to consensus on objective guidelines for what is and isn't allowed (analogous to the unwritten hobby rules about not doctoring cards). It seems everyone agrees that enhancing scans to make the cards look better then they actually are is a problem, but most also have no problem enhancing scans if it gives a more accurate representation of the card. The end result, is that there isn't an objective standard of what type of enhancements are or are not OK (i.e. enhancing sharpness is a no-no), but rather it is about intent.

My Trade/Sale Page