Posted By:
marshall barkmanI agree with you Steve. If you buy a 1884 CC silver dollar in a PCGS MS-63 holder then that is what you get. I don't think you can claim the coin was not graded correctly once you recieve it and then get a refund. I buy cards all the time and in every grade there are true examples of the grade and then there are always borderline ones. I do not agree with the buyer at all in this case. Now the dealer has a card that is talked about and run down plus he has to take the time to deal with the whole situation. If i am uncertain about a card i always e-mail the seller in regards to the condition before bidding. Case in point there was a recent 1952 Willie Mays PSA 4 that looked like a 6 or 7 for 750.00 or best offer, i knew there must be some blemish or something on the card that you cannot see because of the holder, when i e-mailed the guy about condition he stated he felt the card was a 6 to a 8. Now why on earth wouldn't he just re-submit the card?