[Archive]

Posted By: Fred C

Eric,

Many dealers don't offer a return on "graded" cards because they feel that the number on the label should be indicative of the condition of the card.

With grading be "subjective" (and the subjectivity could change from day to day, mood to mood, and/or grader to grader) I would never rely on a number on a label. If I'm really interested in a card I'd ask for full scans (front/back) and a written description.

Would I be disappointed if I received a card without disclosure of damage that wasn't shown? Yes.