Posted By:
AlI'm with the "you crack it you own it" voices. He would have to return the card in the condition it was sent to him...case closed. I wouldn't give this another thought. Sounds fishy to me anyway, like he had another card waiting in the wings to scam you.
Even if the buyer contacts eBay, your position is the card is no longer in the condition it was sent to and received by the buyer. If he was such a big time dealer, he should know better.