Posted By:
Scott Fandangothe centering on the 5 looks worse than it is because the plastic support on the top covers the card just a bit in the scan.....
the PSA 4 is still in the old case so the buyer probably thinks it can be bumped to a 4.5..... old flips garner more sometimes because they have the POTENTIAL to grade a 1/2 higher...
also, the PSA 5 probably has a surface crease on the back you cant see, therefore it received the highest grade possible with a crease (5)....