Posted By:
Phil GarryZach - You're right, my mistake on calling the Just So's cabinet cards when they are not.
The E107 Wagner is still not a rookie card even if you eliminate the M101-1's and NCP's because they are premiums/supplements. You still have the W600 Street clothes Wagner issued in 1902. Would collectors be paying $20K - $30K + for these in nice condition if they were not considering them cards and thus making them fully eligible for rookie card designation? Not only Wagner, but many other w600 HOF'ers have been selling for big, big $$$'s as well lately. So again, if these are OK for rookie status, why not the 1890 Young cabinet? (I know we're back to the method of distribution again)