Posted By:
John H.The guy that sticks in my craw more than any other is Don Drysdale. He simply does not belong in Cooperstown. He made it on the basis of a couple of big years, his name association with Koufax, and the fact that he pitched in LA. Milt Pappas has very similar statistics but nobody's clamoring for Milt's induction. Bill James goes into great depth on the Drysdale case in his book "What Ever Happened to the Hall of Fame?".
Kirby Puckett belongs. He was a great all-around player for all 12 years of his career and he played a key role on two World Series champions. He was also quite possibly the most popular player in the game. There is nothing missing on his resume.
Bruce Sutter was a shaky choice. If Sutter's in, there's a lot of closers, and pitchers in general, that should also get in.
I would rather keep borderline guys out of Cooperstown than let them in. I would hate for the Baseball HOF to become anything like the Hockey HOF.