Posted By:
PCNot too long ago I purchased a BVG 1.5 T206 Reulbach/glove showing for a little less than you did ... $25 with shipping. You got a good price, but then prices have been coming down and some pre-war collectors do not like BVG. The card would have gone for slightly more in an SGC or PSA holder.
As far as it being a rarity, it isn't that rare, and I do not believe it warrants the hefty price some sellers try to get for it. If a "regular" T206 common in 1-1.5 range goes for $15-$20, then an extra $5-$10 for the Reulbach/glove is certainly fair.