Posted By:
marshall barkman A case in point is a guy i know who loves American Beauties bought a card from a dealer in a PSA 9 holder, he thought the card was a 10 so he cracked it out and re-submitted the card and it came back a 7.5, he then cracked it out and it came back a 8, he was so mad he has left the card in a 8 holder because he already has lost about 400 dollars in the grade drop. I also sent scans of my American Beauties to this same gentleman and he wanted to make offers before the grading. He felt about 7 to 10 of the cards would be 9's and there could be a couple of 10's.
I'm not trying to sound like a whiner and i apologize if it comes across that way. What i am trying to do is voice a opinion that the grading card company needs to become more consistent and stop the good old boy games it plays.