Posted By:
carddudethanks for all the quick replies guys!
i also share your skepticism. it does sound too good to be true.
i like the idea of meeting him at the police station... 
if i did decide to meet this guy, should i take a microscope? it seems to be (from my limited research) the best way to tell if they are fakes/reprints or not. (http://www.cycleback.com/baseballcards/index.html)
do any of you have experience evaluating cards with microscopes?
again, thanks for you help everyone!