Posted By:
EricI think we are all getting carried away. I wouldn't classify it as a 1 of 1...
For all we know someone did this a year ago to this card, not 117 years ago. I have this pose Ward and tons of Brooklyn cards, I could make it any day of the week.
What I would strongly suggest is that you do your best to carefully remove the Brooklyn overlay and then send it out to SGC/PSA.
If its going to be graded an AUTH either way, why not encapsulate it in its original format and preserve it as it was meant to be?