Posted By:
Griffins97George- this card was rejected twice by PSA as N8 miscut. It didn't make sense to me, and since the rest of my set was slabbed I wanted this one similarly protected.
I handed it to Mike Baker and he looked at it for 15 seconds and said "psa wouldn't grade it, would they?" I told him they had rejected it, and he explained why it was miscut, how this was done, and why it wasn't trimmed. And why it didn't surprise him that PSA had rejected it.
It's all just an opinion, and they err on the side of caution (and sometimes ignorance). Each company has different standards, and if you're not getting what you believe is an accurate grade take it to someone else. Competition is good for collectors.
