Posted By:
boxingcardmanIt would be a 2 at SGC, so I agree with you there. SGC hammers the snot out of full bleed cards, like Exhibits. I have some really gorgeous SGC 3 1928s that are nicer than some PSA 5 Exhibits I've seen.
When I get PSA cards I always crack and send to SGC; I never bother with a cross-over. I haven't tried to send SGC to PSA. I might with some of my high grade 1971 Topps cards though if I decide to downgrade a touch on my set and use the proceeds to complete it; I think PSA 9's would be easier to sell for top dollar than SGC 96's.
And since it's Monday, let's mention GAI: I've had very bad luck crossing GAI cards to SGC. Rejections for trimming.
Sic Gorgiamus Allos Subjectatos Nunc