Posted By:
Scott Mt. JoyI have done a lot of crossovers to both PSA and SGC.
On crossovers to PSA I always crack and submit, I dont think they are fair at all on crossovers from other companies, I have had them reject over 20 cards that I then cracked and sent in only to get all 20 to grade at min or higher. I no longer send any slabbed cards to PSA. Two tips to help, PSA grades OC and marks/writting as a 2 point drop vs less for sgc and that can make a difference.
On crossovers to SGC, I just send them in whatever slab they are in, SGC grades them strickly on the cards merit not what the slab says, very fair with the grades regardless of the slab company. One tip on SGC is they crush any paper loss (expect around a 20/1.5) vs PSA who is much easier grading it (have seen PSA 4's with slight paper loss)
Good luck!