Posted By:
dennisi do understand what you are saying but all your guys (except vaughn) are 1st tier hall of famers.i don't think anyone would deny these guys their place in immortality.
how about these guys
cather bill freehan all star catcher from 1963 thru 1973
ist base dick allen
2nd base joe gordon lost 3 years to war
ss alan trammel lost in the ripken/arod/jeter love fest
3rd base ron santo was disliked during his playing days by his contempories
lf jim rice most feared hitter during his career
cf dale murphy lost power just as the steroid era began
rf minnie minoso 5 tool player who played in mlb after his prime years
p denny mclain 2 cy youngs and 2 pitcher of the year awards by age 25 & 100 wins
p allie reynolds
p wes farrel 6 x 20 game winner best hitting pitcher ever?
p pilly pierce best lefty in AL besides w.ford in the 50s