Posted By:
Anthony N.I started out 5 years ago trying to build a '15 CJ set in SGC holders, and it's really tough. There is just a lot more available in PSA holders, and a lot of cards get sold and traded between the CU registry participants as well.
Over the years I've cracked about 40-45 SGC graded CJ's to have everything in a consistent holder. While I like SGC's holder a lot better, I prefer an entire set in the same holder for presentation and storage purposes, and it was more economical to go from SGC to PSA on this set for me than the other way round.
I have been a bit amazed (happily so) that virtually every card when cracked was graded at the same level. I know it's a small sample but from my experience the 2 companies are amazingly consistent with each other, with the exception of one set.