Posted By:
John SDenny,
Great question...wish that I had a complete answer. There are definitely levels of scarcity inherent within the E254 set; probably multiple levels. I have been working on this set for over twelve years. I still am surprised when what I believe to be relatively common Colgan's sell for multiples of book value. Of the 290 or so total cards there are still a few that I have never seen.
I am currently working on a checklist that will address your question. The checklist ranks the player/poses on a scale of 1 to 5 relative to difficulty. It probably will not be ready until the summer at which I will post it so it can be critiqued by other Colgan's collectors.
A common player in GD-VG with a tin could probably be had for around $30.