Posted By:
Addie_JossLet's say that is the case, that this is a photo of John but meant to depict Dad Clarkson, who then do you think is represented in the card? Do you consider it a John Clarkson card or a Dad Clarkson card? I forget specifics, but aren't there plenty of other examples of HOFer cards with HOFer names but contain images of a different player? They are still catalogued as the HOFer because of the name and not the image. Is this then a Dad Clarkson card or a John Clarkson card, assuming it is an image of John but meant to depict Dad?
Also, I still think these cards were produced during the 1895 season and therefore any need to differentiate between the two brothers would be unnecessary because John was no longer playing.