[Archive]

Posted By: Rhett Yeakley

John, I would pretty much agree with your groupings, however I don't think the McGinnity is any tougher than the Bresnahan (both relatively difficult though). I have been monitoring the McCarthy for the last several years as well, and was able to pick up a few. If I had to venture a guess on the McCarthy I would say it was pretty similar to the two aforementioned players (McGinnity & Bresnahan). The Flicks are tough, as well as the Waddell minor league cards. All of the Cubs infielders are roughly equal though I have personally seen more Chance than the others, but none of them are tough. It does appear that the Colgan's Gum Co. knew that Wagner and Cobb were the two big draws and printed more of them than everyone else, however I feel I have seen more Wags than Cobb's.

-Rhett
http://www.starsofthediamond.com/colgans.html