[Archive]

Posted By: barrysloate

This thread is going to be controversial no matter how you slice it. But I agree we could do without the personal attacks.

I do think the grading companies have to take the onus of the responsibility if a card is misgraded, and not the auction house. There's nothing wrong with a little good will on the part of the seller, but the issue isn't always black and white.

How many times have the grading companies disagreed, where one company deems a card trimmed and the other one gives it a numerical grade? It might become really difficult to objectively determine who got it right and who was wrong.