Posted By:
Eric BMy thinking is that a 6.5, when cracked and resubmitted, would nearly 100% get at least a 6, probably a 6.5, maybe higher.
The PSA 7 cracked and resubmitted we know won't get a PSA 7.5 or higher (it already failed twice), a good chance it would get a 6, and could get as low as Authentic.
Time will tell. Just my opinion that cards w/o the bump will always be questioned. Heck, even in this example, if the cracked and resubmitted 6 got a 7, folks would question why it wasn't a 7.5.
Lance, I like the term "grading battle". I think I would take the 6.5.