Posted By:
Joe D.I wanted to be post 300. thanks a lot.
Corey -
"if the issue is not clear cut (i.e., one could reasonably argue either way, making it a subjective determination), I would be shocked if a grading company would reverse itself and infuriate its customer base in the process."
with that statement - can we agree that grade reductions CANNOT be made. There is no such thing as a clear cut 1/2 point or 1 point grade reduction. It is subjective.
I have seen cards that should be 3's get a 4 and cards that should be 5s get a 4. That is a 2 point swing... a 2 point range/ margin of error in a 10 point scale.
I agree completely - reversing itself would infuriate its customer base.
And if something counterfeit or ridiculous comes along I am sure PSA will make a phone call.
But to lobby for 1/2 point or 1 point reductions is just ridiculous.
(I know - we just disagree 
its all good)