[Archive]

Posted By: barrysloate

I'm with Corey on this, even if he did misspell "misled" (sorry, I couldn't resist )

It has to be a risk/reward system. You buy a stock with the hope it will go up, but you are keenly aware it may go down. That's a chance you are willing to take when you buy that stock. Likewise, I wouldn't even care if PSA's policy is "we're easy- send us a nice well centered 7 and we'll send it back a 7.5." But they should still give the card an objective reevaluation, as best as they can.

I do agree with Joe on one thing- you could send PSA a 7 that's properly graded, and then they could incorrectly send it back to you in an Auth holder. So in that example it was submitted properly graded and it came back wrong. Absolutely, I agree that is a possibility. So what is the answer? I don't know, I don't have one.