[Archive]

Posted By: barrysloate

I'm still not completely comfortable with a policy that only rewards cards with a half grade bump and will not objectively look at resubmitted cards. You have to assume given the subjectivity of grading, for every undergraded card there's an overgraded one.

And it still doesn't address the issue that a small percentage of altered cards have gotten holdered (even if it's 1-2%, it's still a quantifiable number), and if the grader sees this on a review his hands are tied and he must leave that card as is. That's a gray area that troubles me.