Posted By:
JimBMatt,
I think we have a different understanding of what they were doing before. I think a PSA 5 before half grades included any card that met the minimum requirements for a 5 and everything better up to the hypothetical 5.99. So a 5 was everything from 5.0 to 5.99. Now they have added half grades, so those at the higher end of that scale may now deserve to be in a 5.5 holder. I don't think PSA would agree with you that what was previously in a 5 holder represented everything from 4.51 to 5.49.
JimB