Posted By:
Matt"Given that they just added the half grades after grading 11 million cards, why is it such a big deal that people be able to submit their cards to see if they are worthy of a half grade bump? PSA is not saying we mis-graded 5 million cards. They are saying that some may be strong for the grade and deserve the half grade bump. Things don't have to be complicated all the time.
jimB"
Jim - you're missing the point; no one here is arguing that people shouldn't be allowed to submit cards for re-evaluation. The issue is PSA's guarantee of equal or higher grade. Isn't it likely some cards are now worthy of a half grade demotion? What about the cards in those 11 million that were mistakenly graded the first time?