Posted By:
Joe D.Actually - it seems PSA has gone ahead and quelled any of those concerns. They are the ones who said they will bump or return. So they will not decertify.
JK
If I write on an order a minimum grade... I think they would have to refuse service or abide by the minimum grade. If you are suggesting that the order itself has a spot for crossovers only - I could cross out 'crossover only' or just put my minimum somewhere else.
I have to point out once again... subjectivity. None of the graders want to claim otherwise. This is why they 'do not crack'. They would cause themselves worlds more trouble if they claim to be absolutely accurate. They never do. So, undoing a slab - against the wishes of the owner - either by a competing company or their own has many many more issues and implications than it would appear on the surface.
fed.up: ultimately, these companies can do whatever the heck they want. You mention decertifying. I don't think that is applicable in this context. But of course they can do it. They can also grade every new card that comes in a 9. never higher and never lower. Its up to them. Its also up to us (as consumers) to take their policies in as a whole and decide whether or not they are a worthy place to send our business to.