Posted By:
howardFrank, we are exactly on the same page on that. If those guys are in then Ed should be in (as well as a few others). Some people look at who's in the hall and figure that if player A is in then player B should be also and that makes sense. I guess I look at it the other way around: if Ron Guidry (my favorite) and Ed Reulbach are not in then Rube Marquard and Jesse Haines should not be in.
Howard
P.S. - if the HOF committees agree with me I might have to rethink my position : )