Posted By:
Steve DIn this case I agree that the seller had made a large scan and that was all he needed to do, however that is not to say that any other seller can just scan an over graded card and be in the clear. If a problem exists he/she should also describe such problem that maybe a scan will not show. I am sitting on such a card right now a 55 Topps Koufax rookie graded PSA 8 that the seller did not fully describe and I now have the lemon. Instead of hyping the card (like mine did) he could have described the paper loss that sits right between Koufax's eyes. One day I'll send it to J.O and see what he does. If anyone wants to see it I have it on the registry. WINPITCHER 55 set.
Not that I am losing sleep over it but feel that just because PSA grades it sellers are still liable for fully describing over graded cards.
Steve