View Single Post
  #10  
Old 12-04-2007, 09:37 AM
Archive Archive is offline
Administrator
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 58,359
Default Veterans Committee Results

Posted By: William

Dick Williams? Billy Southworth? So I suppose any manager that had 4 appearances in a World Series should be elected to the Hall-of-Fame.

How long will it be before three trips to the World Series is reason to be elected to the HOF. How long before 2 trips to the WS or 1 trip gets one elected to the HOF?

Automatically have all commissioner's in the HOF and skip the Veterans Committee election.

I think the Veterans Committee should be disbanded anyway. Anyone who retired before 1960 or so that is worthy should be in by now. The other players has 15 years of eligibility to be elected. If they aren't elected by the end of the 15 years, they aren't worthy of the HOF to me.

There has been times that the Veterans Committee did not elect anyone. What did these 5 do since the years no one was elected to make them worthy now?

Reply With Quote