Posted By:
PCMatt -- yours is an excellent question.
Hack is one of the most undervalued pre-war HOFers. On the other hand, top-tier T206 HOFers in all grades are, in my opinion (and I spend a lot of money on T206s), currently very overpriced.
Also, all high grade, graded pre-war HOFers are pricey. With very few exceptions, I would not have any expectation that those cards will aoppreciate at the rate they have in recent years. And who knows, prices have been declining for some issues (33 Goudeys for example), and the higher the grade, the greater the possible decrease in value.
So, purely from an investment perspective, I'm not not sure I would buy either of those cards at this time. But if you're set on buying, maybe hedge a little -- drop down a grade or two, and buy both!