[Archive]

Posted By: Matt

Jimmy - let me make sure I've got the scenario correct - buyer buys JSA authenticated autograph from dealer. Buyer is uncomfortable with the authentication (reasonable in light of the expose) and decides to cross it over to PSA/DNA. PSA/DNA rejects the autograph as being a forgery. The dealer should now, weeks later, take the item back and process a refund?

I will absolutely commend you as a seller if you would honor a refund in that circumstance, but I think it's unreasonable to ask dealers to do that - the pricing on the market is so volatile, you could suffer a significant loss if you allow indefinite returns.