Posted By:
Alan UI haven't had any significant problems with either PSA or SGC although SGC grades are more likely to be available a couple of days early whereas PSA might be a day or two late.
I'm really in the minority because I really like the smaller clear PSA case, however, I don't like it when the card doesn't fit the case and it's just left to flail (sp?) around in the case.
As to value it seems like pre-Goudey cards are the same in SGC or PSA and for Goudey forward, PSA is better.