Posted By:
PaulThe Caruthers is definitely a fake.
A good rule of thumb is as follows: If someone is selling a card "as a reprint," it is a reprint. Period. It is almost inconceivable that a seller -- no matter how ignorant -- would sell authentic cards worth in the thousands "as reprints." Why sell thousand dollar cards for pennies? The only explanation is that they are fake, and the seller is trying to get lucky and find a couple of bidders willing to take a gamble. This seller got lucky.