Posted By:
Derek G.I'm no expert, but I'd probably include the following players:
Orval Overall = 1906 Fan Craze
Bill Joyce = 1895 Mayo Cut Plug
Arlie Latham = 1886 N370 Lone Jack
Dummy Hoy = 1886 Buffalo Bisons ML Team Cabinet
I'm not 100% sure if these are the 1st cards of each, but these are the earliest I've seen of these players.
Also, I'm not sure why everyone and their dog thinks that Hal Chase is a HOFer. He's almost always listed as such in ebay auctions, but he's not.
That's my 10 cents...