[Archive]

Posted By: Tim Newcomb

When I first posted this thread, I was actually thinking the T207 Alex McCarthy looked more like the Colgan's image than like Joe... but now I'm wondering: to me the T200 of Alex looks nothing like the Colgan's, so I'm changing my vote from Alex to Joe. Comparisons of the Colgan's to Joe's manager photos don't tell me anything-- a lot can change in thirty years!

At any rate it's clear that if there were a first name on the Colgan's, it would be Joe, since clearly he was with Toledo and Alex wasn't. So they thought they were picturing Joe, at least.

Anyway, the discussion has been fun to follow--